(236) 361-3888
Free Tool · Hiring Checklist

Web Design Checklist

Use it before you sign with a web designer, and again before launch. Mark what each designer delivers, see a score, and send them the questions it raises.

Start Here
  • Free, no sign-up
  • Runs in your browser
  • Remembers your entries on this device
  • Updated November 19, 2026
A laptop, tablet and phone showing the same clean website design, with color swatches on the desk
  • 18website deliverables ranked by impact
  • 2.5 sor less to load the main content (LCP), per web.dev
  • 200 msor less to respond to a tap or click (INP)
  • 0.1or less layout shift (CLS) for a Core Web Vitals pass

Score Your Web Designer

18 deliverables, ranked from non-negotiable to nice-to-have. Add each vendor you are comparing, or your current one, and mark what they deliver. Your answers stay on this device.

Non-Negotiable

Walk away from any designer who will not commit to these in writing.

  1. You own the domain, hosting and site files

    The domain registration, hosting account, site files and admin login stay in your name, with the designer added as a user. If you part ways, your website stays with you.

    Ask: Are my domain, hosting account and website admin registered to me, and will I get a full copy of the site files?

  2. Mobile-first, responsive design

    Google uses the mobile version of your site for indexing and ranking, and recommends responsive design. Many customers find you on a phone, so the phone layout gets designed first, not squeezed in last.

    Ask: Do you design the phone layout first, and can I review it on my own phone before launch?

  3. A Core Web Vitals pass on mobile

    web.dev sets the pass marks: main content loads in 2.5 seconds or less (LCP), taps get a response in 200 milliseconds or less (INP) and the layout shifts 0.1 or less (CLS). Google's ranking systems use Core Web Vitals.

    Ask: Will the site pass all three Core Web Vitals on mobile at launch, and how will you show me?

  4. A redirect map for every old URL on a redesign

    Google's site move guidance says to map every old URL to its new one and set permanent server-side redirects, such as 301s, kept for at least a year. Without them, the pages Google already ranks turn into dead ends.

    Ask: Will you map every old URL to a new one and set permanent redirects before launch, and can I see the map?

  5. HTTPS on every page

    A security certificate encrypts every visit and removes the browser's not secure warning. Google's page experience guidance checks whether pages are served over HTTPS.

    Ask: Will every page load over HTTPS, with the certificate set to renew automatically?

  6. Analytics and Search Console in your name

    Analytics shows what visitors do; Search Console shows how Google sees your site. Both get set up with you as owner, with the designer added as a user, so the data and history stay yours.

    Ask: Will you set up Analytics and Search Console with me as owner, and track calls, forms and bookings as conversions?

  7. Written scope, timeline and revision rounds

    A written scope lists every page and feature, the launch date, how many rounds of changes are included and what extra work costs. It prevents surprise invoices and stalled launches.

    Ask: Can I see a written scope with the page list, timeline, revision rounds and the cost of changes outside it?

Important

These separate a site that brings in calls from a site that only looks good.

  1. A clear one-liner and one call to action above the fold

    Visitors decide in seconds whether they are in the right place. A headline that says what you do and where, plus one clear next step, does that job before anyone scrolls.

    Ask: What will the top of my homepage say, and what is the one action you want visitors to take?

  2. Phone number and booking always in reach

    A tap-to-call number and a booking or quote button on every page, especially on phones, turn interest into calls without a hunt.

    Ask: Will my phone number and booking button be visible on every page on mobile?

  3. Accessibility to WCAG 2.2 AA basics

    WCAG 2.2 is the W3C standard. Level AA covers readable contrast (at least 4.5:1 for normal text), keyboard use, alt text and form labels, so more people can use your site.

    Ask: Which WCAG 2.2 AA checks will you run before launch, and will you share the results?

  4. On-page SEO built in

    Every page needs a unique title, description and one main heading, plus structured data for your business. Building it in costs far less than fixing it after launch.

    Ask: Will every page have its own title, description, headings and business structured data at launch?

  5. A staging site and sign-off before launch

    A private copy of the new site lets you click through every page, test every form and approve it before customers see it.

    Ask: Will I review the finished site on a staging link and sign off before it goes live?

  6. A plan for backups, updates and security

    Sites need regular backups, software updates and security monitoring. Know who does each, how often, and how fast the site comes back if something breaks.

    Ask: Who handles backups, updates and security after launch, how often, and what does it cost?

  7. Training so you can make simple edits

    A short session or recording on changing text, hours and photos means small updates do not wait on a ticket.

    Ask: Will you train me or my staff to make simple edits, and leave a recording or guide?

Nice To Have

Extras that add value once the essentials are in place.

  1. Speed well beyond the pass mark

    A pass is the floor. Pages that load well under the thresholds feel instant and give you headroom as you add content.

    Ask: How far under the Core Web Vitals thresholds will my main pages load?

  2. A blog or guides section

    A place for answers to customer questions brings in search traffic and gives your sales team pages to send.

    Ask: Will the site include a guides or blog section that I can add to easily?

  3. Room for video

    A short video of you or your work helps people trust you before they call. It needs to load without slowing the page.

    Ask: How will you add video without slowing down the page?

  4. A/B testing after launch

    Testing two versions of a headline or button shows which one brings in more calls, using your real visitors.

    Ask: Do you offer A/B testing after launch, and what would you test first?

Hands holding a phone that shows a website with flowing orange and navy shapes

How To Use This Checklist

The checklist works in two moments: before you sign with a designer, and before the new site goes live.

  • Add each designer you are talking to as its own vendor and score them after each call
  • Mark Not sure for anything they skipped, so it becomes a question
  • Copy the questions into an email and ask for answers in writing
  • Before launch, rescore your chosen designer with the staging site open

Red Flags When Hiring A Web Designer

Each of these costs you later, in money, rankings or both. Any one of them outweighs a high score above.

Domain In Their Name

When the designer registers your domain, leaving them means asking for your own address back. Keep ownership; grant access.

No Redirect Plan

A redesign without a URL map turns every page Google already ranks into an error. Ask for the map before work starts.

Desktop-Only Reviews

Mockups shown only on a big screen hide how the site works on the phones most customers use.

No Written Scope

Without a page list, timeline and revision count in writing, every change becomes a new invoice or a delay.

A long aisle of server racks lit in blue and amber

Why Speed Belongs In The Contract

A slow site loses visitors before they read a word, and Google's ranking systems use Core Web Vitals. Yet speed often gets tested only after launch, when fixing it means rebuilding.

Put the pass marks in the scope. Ask the designer to show a mobile test of the staging site before you sign off. If the site is already live and slow, website speed optimization fixes it without a full redesign.

Core Web Vitals Pass Marks

The speed item above turns on these three numbers from web.dev, measured at the 75th percentile of page loads on mobile and desktop.

MetricWhat it measuresGood
Largest Contentful Paint (LCP)How fast the main content appears2.5 seconds or less
Interaction to Next Paint (INP)How fast the page responds to a tap, click or key press200 milliseconds or less
Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS)How much the layout jumps while loading0.1 or less

The Launch-Day Checks

Launch is where good builds lose their gains. Run these on the day the new site goes live.

  1. Redirects liveSpot-check old URLs from the redirect map; each one lands on its new page with a permanent redirect.
  2. Search Console updatedSubmit the new sitemap, and check the coverage and Core Web Vitals reports over the following weeks.
  3. Tracking firingPlace a test call, send a test form and make a test booking; each shows up in Analytics.
  4. Every page on a phoneClick through the main pages on your own phone: phone number, booking button and menu all work.
  5. Backups runningConfirm the first backup of the live site exists and where it is stored.

Make It A Habit

Score your site once a year, and before you sign for any redesign. Ownership, speed and tracking drift quietly; a yearly check catches a lapsed domain or a slow page before it costs you calls.

Bookmark this page with Ctrl + D (⌘ + D on a Mac), or save it to My Tools. Your entries wait for you on this device.

Questions People Ask

What do I ask a web designer before hiring them?
Ask who owns the domain, hosting and site files when the job ends, how the site will pass Core Web Vitals on mobile, how they handle redirects on a redesign, what the scope, timeline and revision rounds are in writing, and what happens after launch. The checklist above turns each answer into a score.
Who owns my website after a designer builds it?
You do, if the setup is right. The domain, the hosting account, the site files and the admin login belong in your name, with the designer added as a user. Analytics and Search Console too. Check it before launch; untangling ownership after a falling-out is slow and costly.
Will a website redesign hurt my Google rankings?
It does not have to. Google's site move guidance says to map every old URL to its new URL and set server-side permanent redirects, such as 301s, and to keep them for as long as possible, generally at least a year. Skip the redirect map and the rankings your old pages earned go with them.
What are good Core Web Vitals scores?
Per web.dev, a page passes when Largest Contentful Paint is 2.5 seconds or less, Interaction to Next Paint is 200 milliseconds or less and Cumulative Layout Shift is 0.1 or less, measured at the 75th percentile of page loads on mobile and desktop. Google's ranking systems use Core Web Vitals.
What is WCAG 2.2 AA?
WCAG 2.2 is the W3C's web accessibility standard. It has three conformance levels: A, AA and AAA. Level AA, the middle level, includes a contrast ratio of at least 4.5:1 for normal text, so people with low vision can read your pages.

How This Tool Works

Each deliverable carries a weight: 3 for non-negotiable, 2 for important, 1 for nice to have. Yes earns the full weight, Partly earns half, and No or Not sure earn nothing. The score is the share of the total weight earned, out of 100.

Any non-negotiable marked No triggers a warning, whatever the score. A designer at 85 that keeps your domain in its own name, or skips the redirect map on a redesign, is still a risk.

The checklist comes from Google's guidance on page experience, mobile-first indexing and site moves, web.dev's Core Web Vitals thresholds and the W3C's WCAG 2.2, plus what Sherman Hu has seen in full-time SEO work since 2002.

Sources

Everything you type stays in your browser. Nothing is sent to Sherman Hu SEO or anyone else. Saved entries live only on this device until you clear them.

General information, checked against the sources above on November 19, 2026. Google and other platforms change their rules; their current help pages win.

Want Sherman Hu to do this for your business?

Schedule My Free SEO Call