(236) 361-3888
Free Tool · Hiring Checklist

Local SEO And Google Maps Checklist

Use it before you hire someone to manage your Google Maps presence, and every quarter after. Mark what each provider delivers, see a score, and send them the questions it raises.

Start Here
  • Free, no sign-up
  • Runs in your browser
  • Remembers your entries on this device
  • Updated November 19, 2026
A smartphone showing a map with location pins, held up in front of a street of storefronts at golden hour
  • 18local SEO deliverables ranked by impact
  • 4providers compared side by side
  • 0ways to pay Google for a better local ranking, per Google
  • 3phone numbers a Business Profile holds: a primary plus up to 2 more

Score Your Local SEO Provider

18 deliverables, ranked from non-negotiable to nice-to-have. Add each vendor you are comparing, or your current one, and mark what they deliver. Your answers stay on this device.

Non-Negotiable

Walk away from any provider that will not commit to these in writing.

  1. You are the primary owner of your Business Profile

    A profile has only one primary owner. That is you, with the provider added as a manager. Managers can update the profile, post and reply to reviews, but cannot add or remove users, so the profile never leaves with them.

    Ask: Am I the primary owner of my Business Profile, with you added as a manager?

  2. The right primary and secondary categories

    Categories tell Google which searches your profile matches. Google asks for as few as possible, as specific as possible, and representative of your core business. Your primary category names your core business, so it gets checked against what your top map competitors use.

    Ask: Which primary and secondary categories do you recommend, and why each one?

  3. A complete profile: services, hours, attributes and photos

    Google says businesses with complete and accurate info are more likely to show up in local results. Every service, holiday hours, attributes such as parking or accessibility, and real photos of your work all count.

    Ask: Will you fill in every section of my profile, including services, holiday hours, attributes and photos, and keep it current?

  4. A real business name and address, no shortcuts

    Google's guidelines require your real-world business name and a precise address or service area. Keywords stuffed into the name, or a virtual office address, risk a suspended profile and the calls that go with it.

    Ask: Do you ever add keywords to the business name or use addresses where we have no staffed location?

  5. A review system that follows Google's rules

    Google prohibits incentives for reviews, such as discounts or free services, and bans selectively asking happy customers only, often called review gating. A steady system asks every customer, at the right moment, with a direct review link.

    Ask: How do you ask my customers for reviews, and do you ever filter who gets asked or offer anything in return?

  6. Name, address and phone consistent everywhere

    Your name, address and phone number (NAP) on your website, Business Profile and directory listings need to match. Conflicting details confuse customers and give Google mixed signals about your business.

    Ask: Will you audit my listings for name, address and phone mismatches and fix them, and can I see the list?

  7. Monthly reports on calls, directions and website clicks

    Your Business Profile performance report counts calls, direction requests, website clicks and bookings. Those are the actions that turn into revenue, so they belong at the top of every report, compared with last month and last year.

    Ask: Does your monthly report show calls, direction requests, website clicks and bookings from my Business Profile?

Important

These separate providers who move you up the map from providers who send reports.

  1. Replies to every review, good and bad

    Google recommends replying to reviews to show customers their feedback matters. Short, specific replies, never sharing a customer's private details, show future customers how you treat people.

    Ask: Who writes my review replies, how fast do they go out, and do I approve replies to negative reviews?

  2. Weekly Google posts

    Posts keep your profile active and show offers, events, new work and seasonal services right on Google. A weekly rhythm gives searchers a fresh reason to call you over the business next door.

    Ask: How often will you publish posts on my profile, and what will they cover?

  3. Service and area pages with real local detail

    Each main service and area deserves a page that only fits that place: jobs done there, local landmarks, area-specific questions. Google's spam policies treat near-identical pages built to rank for each town as doorway abuse.

    Ask: How do you make each area page unique, beyond swapping the town name?

  4. Local links and citations you can see

    Google says how well known a business is depends partly on how many websites link to it. Listings in trusted directories, local associations, sponsors and press build that, as long as each one is real and named.

    Ask: Which directories, local sites and links will you add each month, and can I see each one?

  5. Map rankings tracked across your whole service area

    Map results change with the searcher's location, so one ranking number tells you little. A grid of check points across your area shows where you appear in the top results and where you fade out.

    Ask: Do you track my map rankings at points across my service area, and can I see the grid each month?

  6. Call tracking that keeps your listings consistent

    Tracking numbers show which calls came from the profile, but a careless setup scatters different numbers across the web. A profile holds a primary number plus up to 2 more, so your main number stays listed and matches everywhere else.

    Ask: How will you track calls from my profile without changing the main number on my listings?

  7. Fake competitor listings reported the right way

    Fake listings and keyword-stuffed names push real businesses down the map. Google's Business Redressal Complaint Form handles fraud or misleading names, phone numbers and websites, with evidence attached.

    Ask: Do you watch for fake or misleading listings in my area and report them through Google's complaint form?

Nice To Have

Extras that add value once the essentials are in place.

  1. A review link and QR code your team uses

    Google suggests asking customers to visit a review link or scan a QR code. Cards at the counter, a line in invoices and a text after the job make asking a habit for your whole team.

    Ask: Will you set up a review link and QR code, and show my staff when and how to ask?

  2. A benchmark against your top map competitors

    Comparing categories, review counts, photos and posts with the three businesses that outrank you shows the gaps worth closing first.

    Ask: Can you compare my profile with the businesses that outrank me in the map, and share what you find?

  3. Fresh photos of real work every month

    Photos of your team, your premises and finished jobs show customers what they get. A monthly upload keeps the profile current.

    Ask: How often will you add new photos, and where will they come from?

  4. Regular strategy calls

    A short call each month or quarter ties the work to your business: new services, busy seasons and towns you want to grow into.

    Ask: How often will we talk, and who will be on the call?

A hand holding a smartphone that shows a map with one highlighted pin

How To Use This Checklist

The checklist works in two moments: choosing who manages your Google Maps presence, and keeping them accountable.

  • Add each provider you are talking to as its own vendor and score them after each call
  • Mark Not sure for anything they skipped, so it becomes a question
  • Copy the questions into an email and ask for answers in writing
  • Once you hire, rescore every quarter with your Business Profile performance report open

Red Flags In Local SEO

Each of these breaks a Google rule or puts your profile at risk. Any one of them outweighs a high score above.

A Promised Map Position

Google says there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking. A promised top 3 spot is a sales line, not a plan.

Reviews For Rewards

Discounts, gifts or payment for reviews break Google's review policy. So does asking only happy customers.

Keywords In Your Name

Adding service words or towns to your business name goes against Google's guidelines and invites a suspension.

Profile In Their Name

When the provider is primary owner, leaving them means fighting for your own profile. Keep ownership; grant manager access.

A shop owner's hands arranging printed review cards with star shapes on a counter

Why Reviews Need A System

Google says more reviews and positive ratings help your local ranking. Reviews also decide which business a searcher calls once they see the map.

The fastest way to lose them is a shortcut. Google bans incentives and review gating, so those shortcuts put your profile at risk. A system that asks every customer, at the right moment, with a direct link, builds a steady stream you keep. The free Google review link generator gives you that link in a minute.

What A Good Monthly Local Report Shows

The report is where accountability lives. Check yours against this list each month.

  1. Actions from your profileCalls, direction requests, website clicks and bookings from your Business Profile performance report, compared with last month and last year.
  2. Searches that found youThe search terms people used to find your profile, so you see which services draw attention.
  3. Map rankings across your areaA grid of positions across your service area, showing where you are strong and where you fade.
  4. Reviews and repliesNew reviews, your average rating and every reply sent.
  5. Work completed and next stepsPosts published, photos added, listings fixed, links earned and what comes next month.

Fighting Map Spam The Right Way

Fake listings and keyword-stuffed names crowd real businesses out of the map. Google's Business Redressal Complaint Form takes reports of fraud or misleading names, phone numbers and websites on Google Maps, with evidence attached. Google does not promise action or send status updates, so a good provider documents each report and checks back. Spam fighting is one part of Google Maps SEO done in the open: every report, listing and link shown to you, in your name.

Make It A Habit

Rescore your provider every quarter with your Business Profile performance report open. Falling calls or a non-negotiable that slips to No tells you to act before another quarter of fees goes by.

Bookmark this page with Ctrl + D (⌘ + D on a Mac), or save it to My Tools. Your entries wait for you on this device.

Questions People Ask

What does a Google Maps SEO company do?
It keeps your Google Business Profile complete and accurate, picks the right categories, posts updates, builds a steady flow of reviews within Google's rules, replies to them, keeps your name, address and phone the same everywhere, builds local pages and links, and reports the calls and direction requests your profile brings in.
Can a local SEO company guarantee a top 3 spot in Google Maps?
No. Google says there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking. Map results depend on how well your profile matches the search, how far the searcher is from you and how well known your business is. A provider who promises a map position is guessing, or planning shortcuts.
Is it OK to offer a discount in exchange for a Google review?
No. Google's review policy prohibits offering incentives such as payment, discounts or free services for a review. It also bans asking only happy customers for reviews. Ask every customer, make it easy with a review link or QR code, and let the reviews fall where they fall.
Does a call tracking number hurt my Google Business Profile?
Google does not publish a rule on tracking numbers. It does require a number under the business's direct control, and a profile holds a primary number plus up to 2 more. A careful setup keeps your main number listed on the profile and everywhere else, so your contact details stay consistent.
Who owns my Google Business Profile if an agency manages it?
You do, if the setup is right. A profile has only one primary owner, and that is you. Your provider joins as a manager, which covers updates, posts and review replies but not adding or removing users. If an agency holds primary ownership, ask for a transfer today.

How This Tool Works

Each deliverable carries a weight: 3 for non-negotiable, 2 for important, 1 for nice to have. Yes earns the full weight, Partly earns half, and No or Not sure earn nothing. The score is the share of the total weight earned, out of 100.

Any non-negotiable marked No triggers a warning, whatever the score. A provider at 85 that holds your Business Profile in its own name, or buys reviews, is still a risk.

The checklist comes from Google Business Profile Help, Google's guidelines for representing your business, its review policy and spam policies, plus what Sherman Hu has seen in full-time SEO work since 2002.

Sources

Everything you type stays in your browser. Nothing is sent to Sherman Hu SEO or anyone else. Saved entries live only on this device until you clear them.

General information, checked against the sources above on November 19, 2026. Google and other platforms change their rules; their current help pages win.

Want Sherman Hu to do this for your business?

Schedule My Free SEO Call