(236) 361-3888
Free Tool · Hiring Checklist

SEO Company Checklist

Use it before you hire an SEO company, and every quarter after. Mark what each provider delivers, see a score, and send them the questions it raises.

Start Here
  • Free, no sign-up
  • Runs in your browser
  • Remembers your entries on this device
  • Updated November 19, 2026
Two printed proposals side by side on a desk, a hand with a pen working down a checklist beside a page with a rising chart
  • 18deliverables ranked by impact
  • 4providers compared side by side
  • 0SEO companies that can guarantee a #1 spot on Google, per Google

Score Your SEO Provider

18 deliverables, ranked from non-negotiable to nice-to-have. Add each vendor you are comparing, or your current one, and mark what they deliver. Your answers stay on this device.

Non-Negotiable

Walk away from any provider that will not commit to these in writing.

  1. You own every account and asset

    Your domain, Google Business Profile, Search Console, Analytics and website logins stay in your name, with the provider added as a user. When you part ways, nothing leaves with them.

    Ask: Are my domain, Google Business Profile, Search Console, Analytics and website accounts registered to me, with you added as a user?

  2. No ranking guarantees

    Google states that no one can guarantee a #1 ranking. A provider who promises one either does not understand search or plans shortcuts that put your site at risk.

    Ask: Do you promise any specific ranking or position on Google? If so, how?

  3. Work that follows Google's spam policies

    Bought links, hidden text and copy-and-paste doorway pages can earn a manual action that removes pages from Google. You need to know exactly what is done in your name.

    Ask: Which link building and content methods do you use, and do they all follow Google's spam policies?

  4. Reporting on calls, forms and bookings, not only rankings

    Rankings are a means. A monthly report that tracks phone calls, form fills, bookings and the pages that drove them shows whether the work pays.

    Ask: Does your monthly report show calls, form fills and bookings from search, and which pages produced them?

  5. A written plan with priorities and a timeline

    A plan lists what happens in the first 90 days, why, and in what order. Without one, months pass on busywork.

    Ask: Can I see a written plan for the first 90 days, with what you will do each month and why?

  6. A log of every change made to your site

    Google suggests asking an SEO to share all the changes they make to your site, with the reasoning. A change log also lets the next person pick up the work.

    Ask: Will you keep a shared log of every change you make to my site, with the reason for each?

  7. A technical audit before new work starts

    Broken pages, slow load times, indexing errors and duplicate pages cap what any content or link work can achieve. Fixing them first makes every later dollar work harder.

    Ask: Will you start with a technical audit and fix list, and share it with me?

Important

These separate providers who move the needle from providers who send reports.

  1. Years of hands-on SEO and a named specialist

    Google's own list of questions for an SEO includes how long they have been in business. Ask who does the work, how long they have done it, and whether you can talk to them.

    Ask: Who will work on my account, how many years have they done SEO, and can I speak with them directly?

  2. Case studies with real numbers

    Results you can check, such as pages ranking in the top three or leads before and after, show what the provider has done for businesses like yours.

    Ask: Can you show me two or three case studies with real numbers, and a client I can contact?

  3. Pages for each service and area, written for that place

    A strong page for each service and each main area you serve, with local detail that only fits that town, outranks one general page. Templated city pages with swapped names do not.

    Ask: How do you make each service and area page unique, beyond changing the city name?

  4. Content that answers what customers ask

    Pages that answer real questions, from price ranges to timelines, earn search traffic and turn readers into calls. A content calendar shows what is coming and why.

    Ask: What content will you create each month, and which customer questions does it answer?

  5. Google Business Profile included

    For a local business, the Business Profile drives the map results, calls and direction requests. SEO that ignores it leaves the biggest local lever untouched.

    Ask: Does your work include my Google Business Profile: categories, services, posts, photos and review replies?

  6. Earned links and local citations

    Links from relevant local and industry sites, plus consistent listings in directories, build trust in your business. Ask where each link comes from.

    Ask: Where will new links and listings come from, and can I see each one?

  7. Clear contract terms and a clean exit

    Know the term, the notice period and what you keep if you leave. The content and pages you paid for stay on your site.

    Ask: What is the contract length and notice period, and what do I keep if I leave?

Nice To Have

Extras that add value once the essentials are in place.

  1. Visibility in AI answers

    Customers now ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Google's AI answers for recommendations. A provider who checks how AI tools describe your business, and fixes gaps, keeps you in those answers.

    Ask: Do you check how AI assistants describe my business, and what do you do about it?

  2. Video and YouTube in the plan

    Video on your pages and a YouTube channel give people another way to find and trust you before they call.

    Ask: Does your plan use video or YouTube, and how?

  3. Help turning visits into calls

    More traffic helps only if the page converts. Clear headlines, a visible phone number and a single next step lift results from the same traffic.

    Ask: Will you suggest changes to my pages that turn more visitors into calls and bookings?

  4. Regular strategy calls

    A short call each month or quarter keeps the plan tied to your business: new services, busy seasons and areas you want to grow into.

    Ask: How often will we talk, and who will be on the call?

Two people reviewing a printed monthly report with charts across a meeting table

How To Use This Checklist

The checklist works in two moments: choosing a provider, and keeping one accountable.

  • Add each SEO company you are talking to as its own vendor and score them after each call
  • Mark Not sure for anything they skipped, so it becomes a question
  • Copy the questions into an email and ask for answers in writing
  • Once you hire, rescore your provider every quarter with the latest report in front of you

Red Flags Google Warns About

Google publishes its own advice on hiring an SEO. These warning signs come straight from it and from Google's spam policies.

A Promised #1 Ranking

Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google. Treat any such promise as a reason to walk away.

Secret Methods

A provider who will not explain what they do, or share the changes they make to your site, leaves you carrying risk you cannot see.

Shortcuts With Links

Buying or swapping links to pass ranking credit breaks Google's spam policies and can cost you rankings.

Accounts In Their Name

When the provider owns your domain, profile or analytics, leaving them means starting over. Keep ownership; grant access.

A ring of keys passed from one hand to another across a desk

Why Ownership Comes First

Every other item on the list is about results. Ownership is about what you keep. Your domain, website, Google Business Profile, Search Console and Analytics hold years of history that Google uses to judge your business.

A good provider asks for access as a user or manager and never takes ownership. If an account is already in a provider's name, ask them to transfer it to you now, while the relationship is good.

What A Good Monthly Report Shows

The report is where accountability lives. Check yours against this list each month.

  1. Leads from searchCalls, form fills and bookings that came from Google search and Maps, compared with last month and last year.
  2. The pages behind themWhich pages brought those visitors, so you know which services and areas are working.
  3. Rankings that matterPositions for the searches your customers use, including in the map results for your main areas.
  4. Work completedEvery page written, fix made and link earned, linked to the change log.
  5. Next month's planWhat comes next and why, tied to the written plan.

Questions Google Suggests You Ask

Google's guide to hiring an SEO lists questions to ask any provider. Among them: examples of past work, whether they follow Google's guidelines, what results to expect and in what timeframe, their experience in your industry and your city, how long they have been in business, and whether they will share every change they make to your site. The checklist above turns those questions into a score you can track.

Make It A Habit

Rescore your provider every quarter, with the latest report open. A falling score, or a non-negotiable that slips to No, tells you to act before another quarter of fees goes by.

Bookmark this page with Ctrl + D (⌘ + D on a Mac), or save it to My Tools. Your entries wait for you on this device.

Questions People Ask

What do I ask an SEO company before hiring them?
Ask who does the work and for how long, for case studies with real numbers, whether they follow Google's spam policies, what they will do in the first 90 days, how they report calls and leads, and whether you keep ownership of every account. The checklist above turns each question into a score.
Can an SEO company guarantee first page rankings?
No. Google states that no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google. Rankings depend on your competitors and on Google's systems, which no provider controls. A provider who guarantees a position is a red flag, not a selling point.
How long does SEO take to show results?
Google gives no fixed timeframe. Its guide to hiring an SEO tells you to ask each provider what results to expect and in what timeframe. A good provider puts that answer in writing, shows early signals such as new pages indexed and rankings rising, and reports leads as they arrive.
How do I know if my SEO company is doing anything?
Ask for a change log of every edit to your site and a monthly report that shows calls, form fills and bookings from search. Score them with this checklist each quarter. Work you cannot see in the log or the report is work you cannot hold them to.
Who owns my website and Google accounts when I work with an SEO company?
You do, if the setup is right. Your domain, website, Google Business Profile, Search Console and Analytics belong in your name, with the provider added as a user or manager. Check it today; moving ownership after a falling-out is much harder.

How This Tool Works

Each deliverable carries a weight: 3 for non-negotiable, 2 for important, 1 for nice to have. Yes earns the full weight, Partly earns half, and No or Not sure earn nothing. The score is the share of the total weight earned, out of 100.

Any non-negotiable marked No triggers a warning, whatever the score. A provider at 85 that keeps your accounts in its own name is still a risk.

The checklist comes from Google's guidance on hiring an SEO and its spam policies, plus what Sherman Hu has seen in full-time SEO work since 2002.

Sources

Everything you type stays in your browser. Nothing is sent to Sherman Hu SEO or anyone else. Saved entries live only on this device until you clear them.

General information, checked against the sources above on November 19, 2026. Google and other platforms change their rules; their current help pages win.

Want Sherman Hu to do this for your business?

Schedule My Free SEO Call