(236) 361-3888
Free Tool · Hiring Checklist

Website Copywriting Checklist

Use it before you hire a website copywriter, and again at every draft. Mark what each writer delivers, see a score, and send them the questions it raises.

Start Here
  • Free, no sign-up
  • Runs in your browser
  • Remembers your entries on this device
  • Updated November 19, 2026
A printed website draft with a red pen and a cup of coffee on a wooden desk
  • 19deliverables ranked by impact
  • 4copywriters compared side by side
  • 79%of test users always scanned a new page, in Nielsen Norman Group research
  • 124%better usability for concise, scannable, objective text in the same research

Score Your Copywriter

19 deliverables, ranked from non-negotiable to nice-to-have. Add each vendor you are comparing, or your current one, and mark what they deliver. Your answers stay on this device.

Non-Negotiable

Walk away from any copywriter who will not commit to these in writing.

  1. A discovery interview or questionnaire before writing

    Good copy comes from your customers, not from the writer's imagination. The writer asks who buys, what they buy, what they fear, and why they pick you over the next business.

    Ask: How will you learn about my customers, my offers and the objections I hear, before you write a word?

  2. A clear one-liner: problem, solution, result

    One sentence that names your customer's problem, your solution and the result they get. Donald Miller teaches it in his StoryBrand framework. It anchors the homepage and every profile you own.

    Ask: Will you write a one-liner for my business that states the problem, my solution and the result?

  3. A headline that says what you offer, for whom, and where

    Visitors decide in seconds whether they are in the right place. A headline that names the service, the customer and the area answers that before they scroll.

    Ask: Does each page headline say what I offer, who it is for, and where I work?

  4. One primary call to action, repeated

    One clear next step, such as Call Now or Book a Visit, placed at the top and repeated down the page, turns readers into leads. Five competing buttons turn them into browsers.

    Ask: What is the one action each page asks for, and where does it appear on the page?

  5. Real proof only: verbatim reviews and real numbers

    Quote real customer reviews word for word, with permission, and use only numbers you can back up. The FTC bans fake reviews and testimonials, and invented statistics cost trust the day a customer checks.

    Ask: Will every review you quote be real and used with permission, and every number come from my records?

  6. SEO built into the copy

    The search term and the place go in the page title, the main heading and the first lines, with one page for each service. Google advises a descriptive, concise, unique title for every page, without repeated keywords.

    Ask: How do you place the search term and my area in each page's title, main heading and opening lines?

  7. You own the copy and get editable files

    The US Copyright Office explains that work by an outside contractor is a work made for hire only with a written agreement signed by both sides. Get the copyright assigned to you in writing, and the copy in a format you can edit.

    Ask: Will you sign an agreement that assigns me the copyright, and deliver the copy in editable files?

Important

These separate copy that sells from copy that only fills the page.

  1. The customer is the hero, not the business

    Copy that talks about the customer's problem and their win holds attention. Copy that opens with the company's history and awards loses it. Your business plays the guide who helps them.

    Ask: Does the copy open with my customer's problem, or with my company's story?

  2. Stakes: what failure costs the customer

    People act to avoid a loss as much as to get a gain. Copy that names what happens if they do nothing, such as a flooded basement or a missed season, gives the call to action a reason.

    Ask: Where does the copy show what it costs my customer to do nothing?

  3. FAQs that handle real objections

    Price, timing, trust and fit stop people from calling. FAQs drawn from questions your team hears every week answer them before the call, in your words.

    Ask: Will you write FAQs from the questions and objections my customers raise, and how will you collect them?

  4. Plain language and a scannable layout

    In Nielsen Norman Group research, most test users scanned pages rather than reading word by word. Short paragraphs, clear subheads and bullet lists let scanners find what they came for.

    Ask: How do you make each page easy to scan: subheads, short paragraphs, lists?

  5. One page for each service

    A page for each service matches what people search and gives each one room for its own proof and questions. One page listing everything ranks for nothing in particular.

    Ask: Will you write a separate page for each of my main services?

  6. Revision rounds and a timeline in writing

    Know how many rounds of changes the price includes, when each draft arrives, and what an extra round costs. Clear terms keep the project from stalling at draft two.

    Ask: How many revision rounds are included, and what are the dates for each draft?

  7. Live samples you can check

    Pages the writer wrote that are live on real websites show their voice, their clarity and how they handle calls to action. Read them as a customer would.

    Ask: Can you show me three live pages you wrote for small businesses?

Nice To Have

Extras that add value once the core pages work.

  1. A short email sequence

    A few emails that follow up with people who ask for a quote or download a guide keep your business in front of them until they are ready to buy.

    Ask: Do you write a follow-up email sequence, and how many emails does it include?

  2. A lead magnet

    A short checklist or guide that visitors trade an email address for turns readers who are not ready to call into leads you can follow up with.

    Ask: Do you write a lead magnet, such as a checklist or short guide, for my visitors?

  3. A Google Business Profile description

    Your Business Profile description is often the first copy a local customer reads. It matches the website's one-liner and voice.

    Ask: Will you write my Google Business Profile description to match the website copy?

  4. A short video script

    A homepage or service video built on the same one-liner and call to action carries the message to people who prefer to watch rather than read.

    Ask: Do you write video scripts from the same message as the website copy?

  5. A second headline to test

    Two headline versions, run one after the other or in a split test, show which one brings more calls. The numbers decide, not opinions.

    Ask: Will you give me a second headline version to test against the first?

Two people talking over coffee at a cafe table, one taking notes in a notebook

How To Use This Checklist

The checklist works in two moments: choosing a writer, and reviewing each draft.

  • Add each copywriter you are talking to as its own vendor and score them after each call
  • Mark Not sure for anything they skipped, so it becomes a question
  • Copy the questions into an email and ask for answers in writing
  • When a draft arrives, score the draft itself: headline, call to action, proof, FAQs

Red Flags In A Copywriting Proposal

The checklist scores what a writer delivers. These warning signs tell you to look harder before you sign.

No Questions About Your Customers

A writer who quotes a price and a deadline without asking who buys from you is planning to write about your business, not for your customers.

Invented Stats Or Reviews

Made-up numbers and polished fake testimonials break trust, and the FTC bans fake reviews and testimonials outright.

Copyright Kept By The Writer

Without a signed agreement that assigns the copyright to you, rewriting or reusing your own pages gets complicated later.

SEO As An Afterthought

Keywords sprinkled in after the copy is done read badly and rank poorly. Search terms belong in the plan from the first outline.

A blank signpost pointing down an open country road under a clear sky

Why The One-Liner Comes First

Every page on the checklist leans on one sentence: what problem you solve, how, and what the customer gets. Donald Miller teaches this one-liner in his StoryBrand framework.

Picture someone at a networking event asking what you do. If you answer in one clear sentence, they remember you and pass your name on. Your homepage gets the same few seconds. A copywriter who nails the one-liner first writes every page faster and clearer after it.

What A Good First Draft Shows

Open the draft and check these in order. Each one maps to an item above.

  1. The headlineIt names the service, the customer and the area in plain words.
  2. The problem and the stakesThe opening lines speak to the customer's problem and what it costs them to wait.
  3. The plan and the call to actionA few simple steps to work with you, and one clear next step repeated down the page.
  4. The proofReal reviews quoted word for word, and numbers you recognize from your own records.
  5. The FAQsThe questions your team hears every week, answered in short, direct sentences.

Copy And SEO Belong Together

Most small business websites get written once, then optimized later by someone else. That split costs twice. When the writer understands search, the page title, the main heading and the opening lines carry the service and the place from the first draft, and each service gets its own page.

Sherman Hu has worked in SEO full time since 2002, and his website copywriting builds search into the copy from the start. Whoever you hire, ask them to show you where the search terms sit in every draft.

Make It A Habit

Once a year, open your homepage and main service pages and score them with this checklist. Offers, prices and customer questions change; copy written two years ago often sells a business you no longer run.

Bookmark this page with Ctrl + D (⌘ + D on a Mac), or save it to My Tools. Your entries wait for you on this device.

Questions People Ask

What does a website copywriter deliver?
At minimum: a discovery interview about your customers and offers, a one-liner, a headline and call to action for each page, proof drawn from real reviews, FAQs that answer objections, SEO built into titles and headings, and editable files you own. The checklist above ranks each deliverable by impact.
What do I ask a copywriter before hiring them?
Ask how they learn about your customers, to see live pages they wrote, how they build search terms into the copy, how many revision rounds the price includes, when each draft arrives, and whether you own the copy outright. Ask for the answers in writing and score them above.
What is a one-liner in website copy?
A one-liner is a short statement of the problem your customer has, your solution, and the result they get. Donald Miller teaches it as part of his StoryBrand framework. It goes on your homepage, your profiles and your business card. Try the website copywriting page for examples.
Do I own the website copy I pay for?
Only if the agreement says so. The US Copyright Office explains that work by an outside contractor counts as a work made for hire only with a written agreement signed by both sides, and only for certain kinds of work. Ask for a signed agreement that assigns the copyright to you.
Does website copy affect SEO?
Yes. Google uses the words on your pages to understand what you offer and where. A page title that names the service and the place, a matching main heading, and one page for each service give Google and your customers a clear match for what they search.

How This Tool Works

Each deliverable carries a weight: 3 for non-negotiable, 2 for important, 1 for nice to have. Yes earns the full weight, Partly earns half, and No or Not sure earn nothing. The score is the share of the total weight earned, out of 100.

Any non-negotiable marked No triggers a warning, whatever the score. A writer at 85 who keeps the copyright, or invents your statistics, is still a risk.

The checklist draws on Nielsen Norman Group research on how people read online, Google's guidance on page titles, the FTC's rule on fake reviews and testimonials, the US Copyright Office's guidance on works made for hire, and what Sherman Hu has seen in full-time SEO work since 2002.

Sources

Everything you type stays in your browser. Nothing is sent to Sherman Hu SEO or anyone else. Saved entries live only on this device until you clear them.

General information, checked against the sources above on November 19, 2026. Google and other platforms change their rules; their current help pages win.

Want Sherman Hu to do this for your business?

Schedule My Free SEO Call