(236) 361-3888
Insights · Marketing Budget

The Year-End Marketing Vendor Review: Check What You Paid For Before You Renew

For local business owners who pay an SEO company, a web designer, an ads manager or a video producer. One hour, six steps, and a clear renew, renegotiate or replace decision for each.

Free Calculator

Marketing Spend Check

Does each vendor pay for itself? Example figures are filled in; replace them with yours.

One lead is worth – in sales.

    Saved on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere.

    A business owner at a sunlit wooden table marks printed bar charts and reports with a yellow pen, beside an open laptop and a coffee mug

    Yes, you can tell whether a marketing vendor earned its fee, and it takes about an hour per year. Gather the invoices and reports, confirm you own every account, divide spend by leads, score each vendor against a written checklist, and check for the red flags Google itself names. Then decide for each vendor: renew, renegotiate or replace.

    This review covers every vendor that touches how customers find you: SEO, web design and hosting, paid ads, social media and video. It asks the same questions of each one, so a $150-a-month hosting plan and a $2,000-a-month SEO retainer get the same scrutiny.

    Why January Renewals Need A Review Now

    If your marketing budget follows the calendar year, or your vendor agreements roll over in January, late November and December are the last quiet weeks to look at the numbers before those dates pass. Once a contract renews, your leverage drops until the next cycle.

    Find your dates first. Open each contract or the vendor's billing portal and write down three things: the renewal date, the notice period, and how notice is given (email, form, letter). A contract with a 30-day notice period and a January 1 renewal needs your notice by early December. This article is not legal advice; your own agreement sets the terms.

    The review matters beyond money. A vendor who holds your domain, your Google Business Profile or your ad account in its own name holds the keys to how customers reach you. Finding that out during a dispute costs far more than finding it out in a calm hour in December. If you want an outside view of your SEO vendor's work, SEO consulting with Sherman Hu covers exactly that kind of review.

    The 60-Minute Review At A Glance

    6steps, about 10 minutes each
    7+accounts to check for ownership
    2numbers per vendor: cost per lead and return per dollar
    3outcomes: renew, renegotiate or replace
    1. Gather the year's invoices and reports for every vendor.
    2. Check ownership of every account and asset.
    3. Match spend to results with cost per lead and return per dollar.
    4. Score each vendor against a weighted hiring checklist.
    5. Scan for red flags from Google's own guidance.
    6. Talk and decide: send the questions, then renew, renegotiate or replace.

    Step 1: Gather The Year's Invoices And Reports

    The review starts with paper, not opinions. Pull every invoice from the past 12 months for each vendor and add them up. Include setup fees, ad spend paid through the vendor, software licenses and one-off projects. Judge the yearly total, not the monthly retainer you remember.

    Next, collect what each vendor reported: monthly reports, dashboards, emails with results. Then pull your own records: call logs, form submissions, booking software, and a count of new customers by month. Your own records are the referee when a vendor's report and your bank account disagree.

    What to collect for each vendor type
    VendorInvoicesTheir reportYour own proof
    SEORetainer, content, link or audit feesMonthly report, change logCalls and forms from search, Search Console clicks
    Web design and hostingHosting, maintenance, domain, plugin licensesUpdate and backup log, uptimeForm fills, site speed, errors you saw
    Paid adsManagement fee plus ad spendCampaign report with conversionsCalls and bookings tagged to ads
    Social mediaManagement fee, boosted postsReach and engagement reportInquiries that mention social
    VideoProduction fees, edits, music licensesDelivered files, view countsLeads that watched or mention a video

    Step 2: Check Who Owns Every Account

    Ownership is the step that protects you most. Each account below needs your business as the owner, with the vendor added as a user or manager. Log in yourself, not through the vendor, and check your role on each one.

    Domain Name

    Look up your domain at ICANN Lookup to see the registrar, then log in to that registrar. ICANN warns that out-of-date registrant email lets unauthorized changes happen without your knowledge, and that ignoring a registrar's request within 15 days can lead to suspension or cancellation of the domain.

    Website And Hosting

    Confirm you hold an administrator login to the site and the hosting account, and that the hosting bill is in your business name or you can move it. Ask for a recent full backup you keep yourself.

    Google Business Profile

    Google Business Profile Help says a profile has multiple owners but only one primary owner. Owners have full control; managers cannot add or remove users or remove the profile. Check your role.

    Search Console

    Only owners see the user list, under Settings, then Users and permissions. Search Console Help says to delete a removed owner's verification tokens too, or they can re-verify. Read the steps.

    Google Analytics

    In Admin, open Access Management at the account and property level. Analytics Help defines Administrator as full control, including adding and deleting users. Your business needs that role, not Viewer. See the roles.

    Ad Accounts

    Google Ads Help lists Admin as the level that gives account access, changes access levels and reviews each user's last login. Hold Admin on your own account. Compare the levels.

    Social pages follow the same rule. On your Facebook page, Instagram account, YouTube channel and any booking or review platform, your own login needs full control, and the vendor gets a lesser role.

    Do this before any break, not during it. Google Business Profile Help states that new owners and managers cannot transfer primary ownership, remove other users or delete the profile during their first 7 days. If a vendor holds primary ownership of your profile, ask to be added as an owner now. Searching for that fix in the week you end the contract leaves you waiting.

    Step 3: Match Spend To Results With Simple Arithmetic

    Two numbers turn a pile of invoices into a decision. Cost per lead is what a vendor cost you for the year divided by the leads it produced. Google Ads uses the same idea for average cost per action: total cost of conversions divided by the number of conversions. Return per dollar is the value of one lead divided by your cost per lead.

    The value of one lead is your average job value times your close rate. The free Lead Value Calculator works it out from three numbers you already know, and it runs on your device. Count only leads you tie to a vendor with your own records: tracked phone numbers, form sources, or a "how did you hear about us" answer.

    A wooden balance scale with a tall stack of coins on one pan and a shorter stack on the other, set on a desk beside printed reports and a pen

    Worked Example: A Two-Van Plumbing Company

    The numbers below belong to an example business, not a real client. Example Plumbing has an average job of $1,200 and closes 30% of its leads. One lead is worth $1,200 × 0.30 = $360 in sales. Its gross margin is 40%.

    Example Plumbing: one year of marketing vendors (example numbers)
    VendorYear's costTracked leadsCost per leadSales per $1Gross profit per $1 (40%)
    SEO$12,00096$125$2.88$1.15
    Google Ads (fee + spend)$18,000120$150$2.40$0.96
    Video (one project)$4,00010$400$0.90$0.36
    Social media$6,0008$750$0.48$0.19
    Website hosting and care$1,800Supports all channelsn/an/an/a

    The math for the SEO row: $12,000 ÷ 96 leads = $125 per lead. Then $360 ÷ $125 = $2.88 in sales for every dollar spent. At a 40% margin, $2.88 × 0.40 = $1.15 in gross profit per dollar.

    Three lessons sit in this table. First, Google Ads looks healthy at $2.40 in sales per dollar, yet at a 40% margin it returns $0.96 in gross profit per dollar: slightly under break-even before repeat business. That is a renegotiation, not a cancellation. Second, social media at $750 per lead returns less than half its cost in sales. Third, hosting produces no leads on its own, so judge it on uptime, updates, backups and speed instead.

    Count repeat customers before you cut. These numbers cover first-year sales only. A plumbing customer who calls again in two years adds value the table leaves out. The Lead Value Calculator adds customer lifetime value when you enter purchases per year and years a customer stays.

    Step 4: Score Each Vendor With A Weighted Checklist

    Arithmetic tells you what a vendor returned. A checklist tells you whether the vendor does the work that keeps returns coming. The free hiring checklists on this site rank each vendor's deliverables in three tiers and score up to four vendors side by side:

    How The Weighting Works

    Checklist weights and what each tier means
    TierWeightWhat it meansSEO example
    Non-negotiable3Walk away if the vendor will not commit in writingYou own every account; a change log of every edit
    Important2Separates vendors who move results from vendors who send reportsCase studies with real numbers; clear exit terms
    Nice to have1Extras once the essentials are in placeRegular strategy calls; video in the plan

    Yes earns the full weight, Partly earns half, and No or Not sure earn nothing. The score is the share of total weight earned, out of 100. Any non-negotiable marked No triggers a warning whatever the score.

    Example Plumbing's SEO provider shows why the warning matters. The SEO Company Checklist has 7 non-negotiables, 7 important items and 4 nice-to-haves, for 39 points in total. The provider earns Yes on 5 non-negotiables, Partly on 1 and No on 1 (it holds the Business Profile in its own name): 16.5 points. It earns Yes on 4 important items, Partly on 2 and No on 1: 10 points. It earns Yes on 2 nice-to-haves: 2 points. The total is 28.5 ÷ 39 = 73 out of 100, with a warning. The return per dollar looks good; the ownership gap still needs fixing before renewal.

    Step 5: Check For Red Flags Google Names Itself

    Google publishes its own advice on hiring an SEO, and its spam policies list the shortcuts that put a site at risk. Both apply to anyone who edits your website or Business Profile, not only to companies with "SEO" in their name.

    Promised Rankings

    Google's guide to hiring an SEO states that no one can promise a top ranking on Google, and advises finding someone else if a provider promises the top spot in search results.

    No Timeframe Or Measure

    The same guide tells owners to ask what results to expect, in what timeframe, and how success is measured. A vendor with no written answer gives you nothing to hold them to.

    Hidden Changes

    Google suggests asking whether the provider will share all the changes made to your site. A vendor with access to your site needs to explain every edit.

    Spam Shortcuts

    Google's spam policies name link spam, including buying or selling links for ranking purposes, plus doorway abuse, scaled content abuse and hidden text. Google warns that sites breaking these policies risk lower rankings or no appearance in results at all.

    Two more warnings come straight from Google's hiring guide. Be wary of SEO firms that email you out of the blue. And avoid any SEO that talks about link popularity schemes or submitting your site to thousands of search engines. The guide also states that advertising with Google has no effect on your site's presence in its search results, so an ads vendor who claims otherwise has it wrong.

    Step 6: The Conversation And The Decision

    The review ends with a short conversation, not a surprise cancellation. Send each vendor the same questions in writing, at least two weeks before the notice deadline. Written answers make vendors comparable and give you a record.

    Two people shake hands across a small round table covered with printed pie and bar charts, with a laptop between them

    Questions To Send Each Vendor

    Copy, paste and send. Edit the brackets for each vendor.

    1. Please confirm that [domain / website / Business Profile / Search Console / Analytics / ad account] is registered to my business, with you added as a user or manager.
    2. What did you deliver this year, month by month? Please attach the change log or work log.
    3. How many calls, form fills and bookings came from your work this year, and how did you measure them?
    4. What results do you expect next year, in what timeframe, and how will we measure them?
    5. Which link building and content methods do you use, and do they all follow Google's spam policies?
    6. What are the renewal date, the notice period and the price for next year, and what is included?
    7. If we part ways, what do I keep, and how long does a full handover take?

    Renew, Renegotiate Or Replace

    Decision table for each vendor
    What you foundDecisionNext move
    You own every account, return per dollar covers cost at your margin, checklist score high, no warningsRenewRenew and set a quarterly score check
    Good results but an ownership gap, or a missing change log or lead reportingRenew on conditionsMake the fix a written condition of renewal, done before the renewal date
    Leads arrive but cost per lead runs near or above break-evenRenegotiateAsk for a lower fee, a shorter term, or a written target for cost per lead
    No tracked leads, vague answers, no plan with a timeframeRenegotiate or replaceGive one quarter with written targets, or give notice
    Promised rankings, bought links, refuses to share changes, or refuses to hand over accountsReplaceSecure every account first, then give notice per your contract

    Applied to Example Plumbing: SEO earns a renewal on the condition that primary ownership of the Business Profile moves back first. Google Ads goes to renegotiation with a cost-per-lead target. Social media, at $750 per lead, gets one quarter with written targets or ends. Hosting renews if the update and backup log checks out.

    Common Mistakes In A Vendor Review

    • Judging on rankings alone. Rankings are a means. Calls, forms and bookings pay the bills.
    • Trusting the vendor's report over your own records. Use your call log and booking software as the referee.
    • Comparing sales to cost without margin. $2.40 in sales per dollar sounds strong until a 40% margin turns it into $0.96.
    • Cancelling before securing accounts. Fix ownership first, then give notice.
    • Missing the notice window. A renewal date matters less than the notice date before it.
    • Leaving old access in place. Remove former vendors from every account, and in Search Console delete their verification tokens.

    What To Do This Week

    Tick these off as you go. Your ticks save on this device, so you can come back to the list over several days.

    If the review turns up a site with problems nobody has explained, an independent SEO audit gives you a fix list to hand to whichever vendor you keep.

    Free Tools For This

    Frequently Asked Questions

    How often do I review my marketing vendors?

    Run the full review once a year, a few weeks before most contracts renew, and a lighter score check every quarter. The free SEO Company Checklist and the other hiring checklists save a score on your device, so each quarter you see whether a vendor is improving or slipping before another renewal comes due.

    What is a good cost per lead for a local business?

    No single number fits every trade. A good cost per lead is one well below what a lead is worth to you. Work out lead value as average job value times close rate, then divide it by cost per lead. The Lead Value Calculator does this math in under a minute with your own numbers.

    Do I own my Google Business Profile if an agency set it up?

    Not always. Whoever holds the owner or primary owner role controls the profile. Open the profile's access settings and check your role. If an agency is the primary owner, ask them to add you as an owner and then transfer primary ownership to you. Google blocks new owners from transferring primary ownership in their first 7 days.

    How do I tell if my SEO company is doing anything?

    Ask for two things: a change log of every edit made to your site, and a monthly report that counts calls, form fills and bookings. Google's guide to hiring an SEO tells owners to ask whether the provider will share all the changes they make. Work missing from the log and the report is work you cannot verify.

    Is it a bad sign if my vendor promises page-one rankings?

    Yes. Google states that no one can promise a top ranking on Google and advises finding someone else if a provider promises the top spot in search results. Rankings depend on competitors and on Google's systems, which no provider controls. Ask the vendor instead what results they expect, in what timeframe, and how they measure them.

    Sources

    1. Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO? (Nov 2026). developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/do-i-need-seo
    2. Google Search Central: Spam policies for Google web search (Nov 2026). developers.google.com/search/docs/essentials/spam-policies
    3. Google Business Profile Help: Manage owners and managers (Nov 2026). support.google.com/business/answer/3403100
    4. Search Console Help: Managing owners, users and permissions (Nov 2026). support.google.com/webmasters/answer/7687615
    5. Analytics Help: Access and data-restriction management (Nov 2026). support.google.com/analytics/answer/9305587
    6. Google Ads Help: About access levels in your Google Ads account (Nov 2026). support.google.com/google-ads/answer/9978556
    7. Google Ads Help: Average CPA (cost per action) (Nov 2026). support.google.com/google-ads/answer/6396841?hl=en
    8. ICANN: FAQs on domain name registrant contact information (Nov 2026). www.icann.org/resources/pages/faqs-f0-2012-02-25-en

    Researched on November 19, 2026. Google's guide to hiring an SEO, its spam policies, and the access help pages for Google Business Profile, Search Console, Google Analytics and Google Ads were read in full on that date, along with ICANN's registrant FAQ. The cost-per-lead and return-per-dollar formulas match the site's free Lead Value Calculator and Google Ads' definition of average cost per action. The scoring weights come from the site's hiring checklists. All dollar figures in the worked examples belong to a labelled example business, not a real client. This article is not legal advice; read your own contracts for renewal and notice terms.

    Want a second pair of eyes on your SEO vendor's year? Book a free 15-minute video call with Sherman Hu.

    Schedule My Free SEO Call